Skip to main content

Blog entry by Kellie Gerard

Deciding whether to rent out the Sacramento house or sell it when you move away usually comes down to numbers and nerves. The rent might cover the mortgage, or it might not. You might want the house waiting for you if you come back.breakfast-and-flowers-for-loved-one.jpg?width=746&format=pjpg&exif=0&iptc=0 Or you might want a clean break and the cash. Nobody can tell you which is right without looking at your loan, your equity, your timeline and your tolerance for late-night phone calls.

If you do rent it, California treats landlords in general terms like a business. You have duties around habitability, meaning the place has to be safe and working, with things like heat, plumbing, and no serious hazards. You have to handle security deposits under state rules, give proper notice before entering, and follow the rules for evictions, which in Sacramento County also means checking local ordinances. Some cities have their own rental rules on top of the state's. Whether your house falls under any of that depends on the situation, so check with the county or the city where the house sits, and get a lawyer for anything you don't understand.

A property manager can take a lot of that off your plate, especially from out of state. They handle tenants, repairs, and the paperwork, for a fee. Interview a few, ask what they charge for, and ask how they handle maintenance and emergencies. A manager doesn't erase your responsibilities, though. You're still the owner.

Taxes are where you really want a CPA. Rental income is generally taxable, and expenses like repairs, insurance, and management fees may be deductible. Depreciation is a thing, and it affects what happens when you sell later. The two-out-of-five-years rule is the one people ask about. In general, if you lived in the house as your main home for two of the five years before selling, you may be able to exclude some gain from capital gains tax. It's not automatic and the details matter, especially if you rented it in between. A CPA can run your specific situation. If you're worried about affording the next place, a HUD-approved housing counselor is free and worth a call.

Selling is simpler in some ways. You get your equity, you stop being a landlord, and you don't have to worry about a tenant calling when the water heater dies. The tradeoff is you give up the future appreciation and the rental income. If the house has a lot of equity and you don't need the money now, renting can make sense. If you need the cash for the next house or you're stretched thin, selling usually feels calmer.

Either way, talk to a CPA before you decide, and a lawyer if you rent. The right answer depends on your situation, and it's worth getting it right before you hand over the keys or the listing.

There is a fuller write-up at rent it out or sell when you move.